Investigating Peter Maniscalco: Understanding Allegations and Exploring Recovery Options

I’ve recently been looking into Staten Island-based financial advisor Peter Maniscalco from Avantax Investment Services, who may have led his clients astray with questionable investment recommendations. For those who have seen their hard-earned money diminish, it’s essential to get to the bottom of this situation, especially regarding a client’s 401K mutual fund selection that could reflect a lack of proper understanding of the client’s investment profile. Here’s the rundown from my investigation.

Unresolved Dispute Drawing Attention to Peter Maniscalco

In the spotlight, we have Maniscalco facing a significant customer dispute as of December 2023. Operating also as Maniscalco Wealth Management and Maniscalco & Picone CPAs out of Staten Island, he’s been flagged for supposedly steering a client towards an unsuitable mutual fund choice leading to a purported loss of $300,000. This matter is still open and waiting for a verdict.

A guiding principle for financial advisors is to tailor investment recommendations to mesh with the client’s needs and financial goals, as underscored by the FINRA Rule 2111 regarding suitability. Advisors are expected to make sure that their suggestions line up with the client’s best interests, factoring in their financial capabilities, risk limits, and objectives. Falling short of these responsibilities can lead to repercussions.

Getting to Know Peter Maniscalco

Peter Maniscalco, pinpointed by his unique FINRA CRD number 4435025, wears multiple hats as a stock broker, financial advisor, and a registered investment advisor primarily based in Staten Island, New York. To my knowledge, he doesn’t use any other aliases professionally.

stock news(AD) Lost money because of bad financial advice or outright fraud? You may get it back by filing a complaint. Haselkorn & Thibaut has 50+ years of experience and a 98% success rate. Don’t delay if you’ve suffered losses. 

Call Haselkorn & Thibaut at 1-888-784-3315 for a free consultation, or visit to schedule. No Recovery, No Fee.

Implications for Clients of Peter Maniscalco

For those who’ve experienced financial harm potentially due to Maniscalco’s alleged missteps, there is a silver lining. Through FINRA’s arbitration process, there’s a pathway to potentially reclaim your losses from brokers like Maniscalco.

When it comes to navigating such complex arbitration procedures, calling upon a veteran securities lawyer can be pivotal. You should also know that if you’re having doubts about how Maniscalco has handled your account, talking with an experienced securities attorney won’t cost you anything upfront.

Financial dealings can often be murky, and advice from advisors might not be as forthright as we assume. Although the accusations against Maniscalco remain unproven, the existing dispute emphasizes the importance of being more alert about our investment decisions and the trust we place in our financial advisors.

In the words of the legendary investor Warren Buffett, “It’s only when the tide goes out that you discover who’s been swimming naked.” This serves as a reminder that the value of solid, reputable financial advice cannot be overstated. Unfortunately, not all advisors are created equal—a fact underscored by a troubling statistic: The Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) reports that through bad practices, investors can lose up to 5% of their earnings due to unsuitable advice from financial advisors.

This fact alone should prompt us to be diligent in our choices, scrutinizing the background, reputation, and integrity of advisors entrusted with our financial futures. With your investments on the line, it’s crucial to ensure you’re working with someone who has your best interests at heart—and whose recommendations are truly designed to benefit you.

To verify the credentials and disciplinary history of a financial advisor, you can check an advisor’s FINRA CRD number. For instance, you can view Peter Maniscalco’s credentials on FINRA’s BrokerCheck through his individual summary available here.

Bringing together my analytical expertise and my passion for imparting knowledge, I am committed to helping you navigate the often intimidating realm of financial decision-making. We all deserve clarity and honesty when it comes to our finances, and I’m here to help ensure that’s what you get. So, if you find yourself in choppy financial waters, remember that you’re not alone, and there are always steps you can take to seek redress and safeguard your investment journey.

Scroll to Top